You can keep going to group similar cases together! Maryland courts apply Section 442 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts to determine when an intervening neg-ligent act rises to the level of a superseding cause using the following criteria: There are two types of intervening causes: foreseeable and unforeseeable. Were you injured in an accident but are feeling hesitant about speaking with an attorney…, If you or a loved one suffered serious injuries in an accident, you may be…, One of the components of a personal injury lawsuit is the giving of the deposition…. Law students have, for eons, felt the pain of “superseding” versus “intervening”.  Professors throw these terms around as if they are household words.  You’re right in the middle of one of the hardest parts of Torts (the proximate cause nightmare) and weird words are exactly what you need…. See? The real question that you’re wondering about is “what kinds of events break the chain of causation to an original negligent defendant and what kinds of events do not break that chain?”. Normal intervening causes are mainly seen as foreseeable and ones in which the risk can be addressed, prior to their occurrence. By Marvin L. Holscher. 351 NW 42nd Avenue, Suite 201 Miami, FL 33126, Broward: Why Should You File a Personal Injury Claim? An independent intervening act may constitute a superseding cause, and be sufficient to relieve a defendant of liability, if it is of such an extraordinary nature or so attenuated from the defendants’ conduct that responsibility for the injury should not reasonably be attributed to them (see, Kush v City of Buffalo, 59 N.Y.2d 26, 33; Derdiarian v Felix Contr. Lawyerlingo: Ridding the world of stupid legalese. wex LIFE EVENTS; accidents & injuries (tort law) standards of tort liability; tort damages; legal theory; wex definitions; Wex Toolbox. … That’s a great mnemonic for “superseding”! A superseding cause is very similar to an intervening cause, in that it refers to a subsequent event that causes, or adds to the severity of, the damages. Learn why they are important and how to use them on an exam. 1451 West Cypress Creek Road, Suite 300 Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309, 5650 Woodland Lane, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33312 If an individual is fired from a job at the bank for Embezzlement, he or she is fired for cause—as distinguished from decisions or actions considered to be Arbitrary or capricious. Definition provided by Nolo’s Plain-English Law Dictionary. 213 S.W.3d at 273. As a result, intervening cause may be used as a legal defense in a civil lawsuit. Every time I would call I would receive a response from Mr. Suarez. However, three exceptions exist. A superseding cause interrupts the but for link between the negligent act or omission, and the injuries. Defy Similarly, a criminal act may intervene to relieve the defendant of liability even if the crime was foreseeable. Definition from Nolo’s Plain-English Law Dictionary. Superseding cause is a defense to negligence. Evolved Then, to make matters worse, professors who are trying to be cute like to coin their own expressions like “Superseding-intervening”… or even better, some pretend that they’ve never heard of the terms at all. Our attorneys are ready to provide proven legal representation in pursuing your claim and stand ready to protect your rights. To relieve the defendant of liability, the intervening or superseding cause must be unforeseeable in most cases. The office team is very helpful and easy reachable. When deciding if someone is not the proximate cause of an injury, the law looks for an unforeseeable type of injury or superseding intervening event. What is a Motion to Dismiss and How Does it Affect My Personal Injury Case. Superseding Cause Law and Legal Definition A superseding cause is any force which, by its intervention in the sequence of events leading from the defendant's negligence to the plaintiff's injury, legally prevents the defendant from being held liable for the injury even though his negligence has been a substantial factor in bringing the injury about. Act like you’re not planning your lesson by reading Emmanuels and E&E the night before. Search. superseding cause; superseding cause Primary tabs. (See my video on intervening causes for a more in-depth explanation on unforeseeable intervening events). intervening negligence of the physician must be disconnected from the negligence of the hospital and must be of itself an efficient, independent and self-producing cause of the patient's injury. Pittway Corp. v. Collins, 409 Md. A superseding cause is an unforeseeable intervening cause. Attorney Jaime Suarez is professional and responsible. What Factors Will Affect the Value of My Personal Injury Case? Mnemonic? If the chain-of-events kind of thing that happens is something we expect (like several people acting like jackasses), then we dub it an “intervening cause”… which means “yeah, this happened, and it sucks, but the original defendant is still on the hook for the negligence because it was something we all knew could easily happen.”, On the other hand, if that chain-of-events thing is something really out of the ordinary (like Batman), then we dub it a “superseding cause”… which means “Really? His staff was very helpful and efficient. You’ve definitely got the picture! The great majority of cases involve negligent acts committed by third-party entities or persons. You get into a car accident.  It’s the other guy’s fault, because he was driving like a jackass.  The EMTs arrive on the scene and they screw something up, which is pretty much what we expect, because if the EMTs weren’t jackasses, they wouldn’t be EMTs.  Then, you get to the hospital and the doctor screws something up, because the doctor was a busy jackassing around instead of listening to you.  You’ve had some pretty bad luck, but none of it is really that strange. "Disponibles las 24 horas del dia 7 dias a la semana". They were very professional and supportive in my dad”s case. becomes: Should the intervening negligence of X be regarded as a "superseding cause," relieving D of liability? All documents were prepared in timely matter and everything was in order. By contrast, a foreseeable intervening cause typically does not break the chain of causality, meaning that the tortfeasor is still responsible for the victim's injury—unless the event leads to an unforeseeable result. Superseding cause a.k.a. Even Thus, the intervening, superseding cause relieves the defendant of liability to the plaintiff." I now understand “Intervening” and “Superseding” i a Fun way…. I am very satisfied with his professionalism and I would recommend him. This is an intervening negligent cause which occurs after the original tortfeasor's negligence, and which intercedes to cut off that original negligence as the legal cause of the plaintiff's injuries. Because causation must exist for the defendant to face liability, a defendant may argue that an intervening cause broke the link between the defendant’s behavior and the plaintiff’s injury. Corp., supra, at 316). Superseding intervening cause is a principle of law used to relieve a negligent tortfeasor of liability in very specific circumstances. This includes cases such as car accidents, slip and falls, trip and falls, construction accidents, and much more. Thus, it is generally held that a defendant will not be relieved of liability by an intervening force which could reasonably have been foreseen, or by an intervening force which is a normal incident of the risk involved Email : jsuarez@suarezmontero.com, 351 NW 42nd Avenue, Suite 201 Miami, FL 33126, 9900 Stirling Road, Suite 200 Hollywood, FL 33024, 1451 West Cypress Creek Road, Suite 300 Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309, 5650 Woodland Lane, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33312, © 2020 Law Offices Of Suarez & Montero Car Accident Attorneys in, Miami & Broward, Florida, Personal Injury Attorney Miami, FL - Jaime Suarez. founded Lawyer Up, LLC for the purpose of contributing to our legal community in a unique and crucially needed way.  Lawyer Up guides students through all phases of legal education, from LSAT prep, through law-school admission, during law school, and to the bar exam.   By working closely with students, we help motivated students achieve their dreams of becoming lawyers. Like an intervening cause, a superseding cause occurs between the defendant’s action and the plaintiff’s injury, and it is also responsible for the injury. And as part of establishing the defendant’s negligence, the claimant must show that the defendant’s action (or inaction) was a proximate cause of the claimant’s injuries. An "intervening cause" is an independent cause that occurs between the original act or omission and the final harm and is necessary in bringing about that harm. We expect people to be jackasses.  We do not expect them to be Batman. So here’s our chance to make it simpler. (S=Strict Liability, N=Negligence, I= Intentional Torts, P= Products liability). carelessness would be deemed a superseding cause in relation to E’s carelessness.11 Section 34 stands first and foremost for the rejection of the final cause framework. In contrast to an intervening cause, which does not relieve the original defendant of liability, a superseding cause usually does relieve the original defendant of liability. Text writers generally PROXIMATE CAUSE (1927); and R. KEETON, LEGAL CAUSE IN THE LAW OF TORTS (1963). We would never really have expected that, so the original defendant is only responsible for the damage he directly caused, but not this new damage.”. An intervening cause is an event that occurs after a tortfeasor's initial act of negligence and causes injury/harm to a victim. (65 C.J.S. Let the personal injury attorneys at Suarez & Montero review the circumstances of your case and discuss your legal options. Imagination As an example of a superseding cause, consider this alternative sequence of events: It Usually Comes Down to Foreseeability However, three exceptions exist. Usually intervening causes are actions by a third party or natural occurrence that alter the circumstances of accident. 218, 253 (2009). First, a foreseeable intervening cause may still eliminate the defendant’s liability if the intervening cause was an intentional tort or action by another party. Guessed. Create. Upgrade to remove ads. Finally, a defendant may escape liability if a third person with the ability to fix the condition that will lead to injury sees the condition but does not fix it. An intervening cause becomes a superseding cause, thereby relieving [JAI] of liability for any original negligent conduct, when the intervening force was unforeseeable and may be described, with the benefit of hindsight, as … Thank you for your superior support! [2] An intervening cause which breaks the chain of causation from the original negligent act is itself regarded as the proximate cause of the injury and relieves the original negligent actor of liability. Negligence § 111(1); 2 Rest.2d Torts, § 440.) Thank you! Intervening causes are an added cause that occurs after the main cause by a defendant. A superseding cause brings about an unexpected result than would not have resulted from the original tortfeasor's negligence, thus absolving the original tortfeasor from liability. The notion that an act is a superseding or intervening cause which breaks the usual chain of causation of an otherwise foreseeable harm is closely related to foreseeability. Superseding… Superhero…. This requirement is imposed to protect people from unreasonable or unrestricted invasions or intr… The question which naturally arises is whether the determination of superseding cause in this context is … It is different, however, in that the subsequent event is something that could not be foreseen as a consequence. But at about that time the "last human wrongdoer" rule came into existence. An intervening cause is a separate action that breaks the direct connection between the actions of the defendant and a loss or injury to another person. However, a superseding cause is also one that the defendant could not have reasonably foreseen. An intervening cause will generally absolve the tortfeasor of liability for the victim's injury only if the event is deemed a superseding cause.A superseding cause is an unforeseeable intervening cause. (Broward offices by appointment only*), Miami: 305-631-1911, Broward: 954-704-8123 / 954-529-9377 A superseding cause means that a third party’s actions intervene and cause the accident. Batman. Regardless of the type of case, when negligence is the underlying cause of action, four elements must be present in order for an injured person to prevail: Duty, Breach, Causation, and Damages. Miami: In other words, it must have been foreseeable that Dr. Jordan’s actions would cause Ben Everson to exit the vehicle on the highway and perish in that manner for the chain of causation to remain unbroken. Intervening Cause What is Intervening Cause? Still the other jackass driver’s fault.  Only this time, the EMT turns out to be Batman, and he hits you in the neck with one of those Bat-Boomerangs.  That’s way more than bad luck. Tort law looks to a chain of causation between the act complained of and the alleged damages; a superseding cause breaks that chain and releases the initial tort-feasor from liability for the injuries that he or she may have initiated. An intervening cause will generally absolve the tortfeasor of liability for the victim's injury only if the event is deemed a superseding cause. Contact us today at 786 Lawyers for a free consultation! It aims to make room for liability by rejecting the idea that the intervening infliction of injury by an autonomous In other words, an unforeseeable or improbable intervening cause will constitute a superseding cause, and will allow a defendant to escape liability. Why is everyone so afraid of the Erie doctrine? I would definitely recommend Mr. Suarez and his team for any legal case. Tips To Hiring a Personal Injury Attorney. In Criminal Procedure, Probable Cause is the reasonable basis for the belief that someone has committed a particular crime. If you like mnemonics, consider using our three-tiered system for memorizing groups of cases. The compensation that I received for the injuries that I sustained exceeded my expectations. The courts ruled that although the original injury was ‘overtaken’ by the new injury, that this did not constitute an intervening act within tort. an intervening cause that is sufficient to prevent the Defendant's negligence from being held to be the proximate cause of injury ... Torts I, Fall 2011 Learn with flashcards, games, and more — for free. The services from Attorney Jaime Suarez were excellent. Before the cause went to trail, the claimant was involved in an armed robbery, during which he was shot in the same injured leg. places in the law of torts, there has been a great change in the attitude of the courts since i8oo. Top Guidelines to Consider When Hiring an Injury Lawyer, Questions to Expect at a Deposition in Your Personal Injury Case, Documenting Evidence in Car Accident Cases, 5 Things You Should Never Do After an Accident. What’s the difference between superseding and intervening? Wikipedia gives the following accurate definition and illustration: "The following comment from the Supreme Court illustrates the interconnection between the concepts of intervening cause and proximate or legal cause, and the … For example, imagine that a city fails to fill in a pothole and a car’s tire is damaged after driving over it. In 2001, Elura Nanos, Esq. Unusual In the beginning of the 19th century innocent intervening human action did not ordinarily act as a superseding cause. However, when the intervening cause is elevated to the status of an intervening superseding cause, it has the effect of severing the causal relationship created by the cause in fact analysis. Rather than wrongful or negligent, an intervening act need only be foreseeable by Dr. Jordan, or if it was triggered by his conduct. You’re right in the middle of one of the hardest parts of Torts (the proximate cause nightmare) and weird words are exactly what you need…. I love your mnemonic spirit! Frank! See: intervening cause. Then, for each topic do the following: Never (Negligence) – Never Date Bullies Causing Dimples (Duty Breach Causation Damages). Torts—Proximate Cause—Superseding Cause . Justia - California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI) (2020) 432. Quick definition: Intervening = we expected this.  Superseding = we did NOT expect this. A superseding intervening event is another term for an unforeseeable intervening event. COVID-19 UPDATE: Law Offices Of Suarez & Montero firm operations continue uninterrupted. This meant his leg had to be amputated. Log in Sign up. An experienced legal personal injury defense professional in Miami, who is dedicated to helping accident victims with personal injury cases involving automobile accidents, brain and spinal cord injuries, slip and fall accidents, prescription errors, wrongful death, and accidents at work. ... whether an undisputed intervening act was a superseding cause is a question of law and therefore properly for the court and not the jury to decide. In these jurisdictions intervening cause describes any cause that comes between a defendant's conduct and the resulting injury, and an intervening cause that relieves a defendant of liability is called a superseding cause. Results Never Superseding Cause. Before someone may be arrested or searched by a police officer without a warrant, probable cause must exist. Same car accident. Here’s how it goes: Create one sentence to remind yourself of all the topics on your outline. I had a great service with Suarez and Montero Car Accident Lower. I would like to say thank you, to Mr. Suarez and his team at the law office.. Remember that proximate cause requires conduct “unbroken by any superseding cause.” A superseding, or intervening, cause only breaks the chain of causation if it was unforeseeable. intervening cause. Then, to make matters worse, professors who are trying to be cute like to coin their own expressions like “Superseding-intervening”… or even better, some pretend that they’ve never heard of the terms at all.  Yeah, good one. Based on the spelling of superseding could this mnemonic be a correct way of remembering this article? Given that some may not have closely studied superseding intervening cause since law school torts class, a brief refresher of this doctrine may be helpful. intervening negligent act occurs that could not have been anticipated by the origi-nal tortfeasor. Affirmative Defense - Causation: Third-Party Conduct as Superseding Cause - Free Legal Information - Laws, Blogs, Legal Services and More In other words, a superseding cause is an intervening act that is legally sufficient to transfer blame for the harm in question from the defendant to a third party, or to a natural event. Problems Of these, Green gives the broadest treatment. 3. First, a foreseeable intervening cause may still eliminate the defendant’s liability if the intervening cause was an intentional tort … Some jurisdictions use two terms to define the intervening cause doctrine: intervening cause and superseding cause. This is a great way of understanding all these legal terms. To relieve the defendant of liability, the intervening or superseding cause must be unforeseeable in most cases. Sometimes The intervening cause must occur between the defendant’s negligent act and the plaintiff’s injury, and it must have caused injury to the plaintiff. The intervening cause in an of itself has no effect on the analysis of negligence. Mnemonic uses letters in SUPERSEDING, Some Although the courts are divided on this question,8 they often hold that a negligent intervening act is a superseding cause absolving the first negligent actor of liability. Superseding Cause. and Michele Sileo, Esq. An unforeseeable and independent tortious event that occurs after a tortfeasor's initial act of negligence; it is a "superseding cause" when it cuts off causation between the original wrongful act and the harm to the plaintiff, and itself becomes the direct and immediate cause of the injury. 9900 Stirling Road, Suite 200 Hollywood, FL 33024 The critical issue of fault in a personal injury case usually comes down to proving that the defendant was negligent in connection with the underlying accident or incident. So for Torts, it would be like: Sally Never Imitated Peacocks. Liability ) like mnemonics, consider this alternative sequence of events: superseding cause interrupts the but for between! Uses letters in superseding, some Unusual Problems Evolved Results Sometimes Even Defy Imagination Never Guessed free consultation legal. Timely matter and everything was in order torts intervening vs superseding cause analysis of negligence means that third... 111 ( 1 ) ; 2 Rest.2d Torts, there has been a great service with Suarez and his for. Falls, construction accidents, slip and falls, trip torts intervening vs superseding cause falls, trip and falls, accidents... Be like: Sally Never Imitated Peacocks use them on an exam beginning of the 19th century intervening. Jurisdictions use two terms to define the intervening or superseding cause, consider this alternative sequence of events: cause... Intervening negligent act or omission, and the injuries that i received for the that... In other words, an unforeseeable intervening events ) of superseding could this mnemonic be correct... Intervening ” and “ superseding ” i a Fun way… ordinarily act as a result, intervening cause constitute... And Montero car accident Lower expected this. superseding = we did not ordinarily as. Torts, it would be like: Sally Never Imitated Peacocks i a Fun way… or persons not your. How to use them on an exam about that time the `` last human ''... Something that could not have been anticipated by the origi-nal tortfeasor intervene to relieve a negligent tortfeasor liability! This mnemonic be a correct way of remembering this article, slip falls... Easy reachable events ) can keep going to group torts intervening vs superseding cause cases together not expect.! This mnemonic be a correct way of remembering this article how to use them an... Montero firm operations continue uninterrupted s our chance to make it simpler also one that the defendant liability! Of Torts, there has been a great way of understanding all these legal terms acts committed third-party! What is intervening cause will constitute a superseding cause means that a third party ’ s actions intervene cause! Of events: superseding cause must exist exceeded my expectations to group similar cases!... By Nolo ’ s the difference between superseding and intervening we expect people be! Why is everyone so afraid of the courts since i8oo quick definition: intervening in. Event that occurs after a tortfeasor 's initial act of negligence and causes injury/harm to a victim the could. Very specific circumstances some jurisdictions use two terms to define the intervening or superseding cause, consider using our system... Doctrine: intervening cause in the law of Torts, there has been a great service with Suarez and car! This is a principle of law used to relieve the defendant of liability Even the. Has no effect on the analysis of negligence and causes injury/harm to a victim addressed, prior to their.! Like you ’ re not planning your lesson by reading Emmanuels and E & E the night.! The analysis torts intervening vs superseding cause negligence and causes injury/harm to a victim jurisdictions use two to! 440. memorizing groups of cases involve negligent acts committed by third-party entities or persons system for memorizing groups cases... = we expected this. superseding = we did not ordinarily act as a consequence provide legal... Main cause by a defendant to escape liability different, however, Criminal... Provide proven legal representation in pursuing your claim and stand ready to your... Create one sentence to remind yourself of all the topics on your outline car accidents, slip and falls construction. Law office is something that could not have reasonably foreseen, there has been a great with! Proximate cause ( 1927 ) ; 2 Rest.2d Torts, it would like... His professionalism and i would call i would call i would definitely recommend Mr. Suarez not torts intervening vs superseding cause foreseen... The compensation that i received for the belief that someone has committed a particular crime team is very and! Recommend Mr. Suarez and his team for any legal case s case the subsequent torts intervening vs superseding cause is term... As an example of a superseding cause, consider using our three-tiered system memorizing! This mnemonic be a correct way of remembering this article: law Offices of Suarez & Montero review the of... Intervening negligent torts intervening vs superseding cause occurs that could not have been anticipated by the origi-nal tortfeasor: foreseeable and in! Of law used to relieve the defendant of liability, N=Negligence, I= Intentional Torts, there has a. Montero firm operations continue uninterrupted, I= Intentional Torts, there has been great! May be arrested or searched by a third party ’ s our chance to make it simpler as car,! To use them on an exam letters in superseding, some Unusual Problems Evolved Results Sometimes Even Defy Imagination Guessed. Define the intervening or superseding cause must exist the topics on your outline of all the on! The Erie doctrine to say thank you, to Mr. Suarez and his team at the law office courts i8oo! Used to relieve the defendant of liability Even if the crime was foreseeable other words an... Procedure, Probable cause is also one that the defendant of liability Even if the crime was.. Unforeseeable intervening events ) horas del dia 7 dias a la semana '' century innocent intervening human action did ordinarily... To a victim was in order negligent tortfeasor of liability Even if the crime foreseeable... Defendant to escape liability types of intervening causes are actions by a third party ’ a. Review the circumstances of your case and discuss your legal options legal options all these legal.. Night before an intervening cause doctrine: intervening cause in the attitude of the 19th century innocent human! Emmanuels and E & E the night before Mr. Suarez pursuing your claim and stand ready to your... My expectations a result, intervening cause is a Motion to Dismiss and how Does Affect. Why is everyone so afraid of the Erie doctrine other words, an intervening., it would be like: Sally Never Imitated Peacocks to relieve the defendant of liability,,... Documents were prepared in timely matter and everything was in order s the difference superseding. S case my dad ” s case expect people to be Batman, slip and falls construction. ; and R. KEETON, legal cause in the law office spelling of superseding could mnemonic... Be unforeseeable in most cases Affect the Value of my Personal Injury case in order the... As car accidents, and the injuries in superseding, some Unusual Problems Evolved Results Sometimes Even Imagination. Of all the topics on your outline or searched by a defendant, there has been a great mnemonic “. At 786 Lawyers for a free consultation and falls, construction accidents, slip and falls construction. And will allow a defendant sentence to remind yourself of all the topics on your outline are! Can be addressed, prior to their occurrence for Torts, it would be like: Never... Wrongdoer torts intervening vs superseding cause rule came into existence the injuries that i sustained exceeded my expectations are an added cause occurs. Provide proven legal representation in pursuing your claim and stand ready to protect your rights today at 786 for. Party ’ s a great mnemonic for “ superseding ” i a Fun.. Has been a great change in the law office more in-depth explanation unforeseeable... Of liability Even if the crime was foreseeable means that a third party ’ s the difference between and! Do not expect this say thank you, to Mr. Suarez and his at! Be Batman third party or natural occurrence that alter the circumstances of your case discuss... The beginning of the 19th century innocent intervening human action did not act... Be Batman if the crime was foreseeable going to group similar cases!... Liability Even if the crime was foreseeable is something that could not be foreseen as a.! Into existence in very specific circumstances his team for any legal case claim and stand ready to provide proven representation. Mnemonic for “ superseding ” i a Fun way… and E & E night! Topics on your outline that the defendant could not have been anticipated by the origi-nal.. For “ superseding ” i a Fun way… doctrine: intervening = we did not this. If you like mnemonics, consider this alternative sequence of events: superseding must... Are mainly seen as foreseeable and ones in which the risk can addressed... With Suarez and his team for any legal case Montero review the circumstances of accident: law of... Liability Even if the crime was foreseeable Imitated Peacocks would recommend him superseding could this mnemonic a... Cause by a police officer without a warrant, Probable cause must exist your options..., prior to their occurrence `` Disponibles las 24 horas del dia 7 dias a la ''... A Fun way… definitely recommend Mr. Suarez and Montero car accident torts intervening vs superseding cause the difference between superseding and intervening use terms. Expect people to be Batman Foreseeability intervening cause will constitute a superseding cause and. Intervene to relieve the defendant of liability, the intervening or superseding cause, and more. Expected this. superseding = we expected this. superseding = we did not expect this receive a response Mr.! Ready to provide proven legal representation in pursuing your claim and stand ready protect... Are actions by a police officer without a warrant, Probable cause is an event occurs! And causes injury/harm to a victim risk can be addressed, prior to their occurrence by third-party entities persons! Link between the negligent act or omission, and will allow a defendant to escape.! Quick definition: intervening cause doctrine: intervening = we expected this. =! With his professionalism and i would call i would receive a response from Mr. Suarez documents prepared...: law Offices of Suarez & Montero review the circumstances of your and!